Total Pageviews

Sunday 24 February 2013

Dear #radfem2013 Intersectionality Is Essential

Dear #Radfem2013

I have been watching your hashtag with interest over the past few days as I know you've been having a conference. Let me say I like a lot of what you say and in my dark hours, I have actually thought I might want to join you.

But I can't. And that isn't my fault, it's yours. And it makes me really sad. Not for me, I'm more than happy in my feminism thanks, but for you who must know, deep down, that you will never achieve what you want because, believe it or not, you are not about equality for women.

I hope you were sat down for that. I can almost hear your bristling and outrage. And I'm ready for whatever backlash you want to throw at me. But I'm not actually expecting any to be honest because as an intersectional feminist, I am beneath your intellectual notice. Though you are not above pouring scorn and hatred on my ilk.

You exclude me, and feminism shouldn't, fuck it, DOESN'T work like that.

So, here is why I don't want to be part of your faux revolution.

I am a woman who understands that every woman, regardless of gender assignment at birth is my sister. No, she wasn't 'born a man', she was born a woman. And no, escaping misogyny for most of her life (are you fucking shitting me here? It is patriarchy that means so many trans* women commit suicide) does not mean that she is a threat to women only spaces because she brings a male perspective. We don't punish women for being women. I say 'we', I mean us intersectional feminists. You still see them as 'chicks with dicks' and you should be ashamed.

I have a boyfriend. He is a man. He is also the best feminist ally you could hope for. He listens to us without trying to fix us. He doesn't try to tell us what we need. He never judges. He will debate our issues with us to understand them so he can help in a way that we want him to, not in a way that makes it look like he knows best because he is a man. He will challenge misogyny and not accept it in his presence. He will educate other men. He will not mansplain. He believes that women deserve equality as a default, NOT because men would bestow it upon us as a gift. He is an ally, and there are many more like him.

Yet you would write him off as TEH MENZ and call him TEH PROBLEMZ.

You really don't like gay men do you? You think that they hate women and are all about the misogyny themselves. You miss the point that their struggle is equal to our struggle and that we might have something to learn from each other. And that they are actually, in the main, our allies too. You see they understand about being oppressed. It wasn't that long ago that being themselves actually meant prison. And dammit, they know how to campaign and organise. Talk to them, you might surprise yourselves.

You talk about gynecology being born from vivisection of slaves. But that seems to be as far as you would go to talk about Women of Colour. I don't deny this, but that same gynecology saves millions of women's lives. So what is your point? Ah yes, that TEH MENZ WAZ EVILZ. *yawn*. Talk about the rape of women of colour, but what campaigns do you actually support to help?

Getting more and more angry here and that wasn't my intention, so will give you the last reason I want nothing to do with your ridiculous, bigoted, hateful organisation.

I am the mother of two boys. They are good men who understand our issues and will fight to make sure that we get the equality due to us. I cannot reconcile your hatred and mistrust of men with the ones I have raised. And here is the crux of the matter, when they are arguing on our behalf with other men who don't get feminism and do need educating it is you that gets thrown at them as an example of why feminism is a BAD thing.

It is you that gets thrown at them as an example of feminism being full of man hating psychos who hate everyone to be honest. It isn't us who spend our time educating, protesting outside abortion clinics when the disgusting 40 Days Of Life are harassing women. It isn't us who are trying our hardest to affect change in the Left because we understand that holding ourselves separate from them isn't going to achieve anything. No, it isn't us who understand that without intersectionality our fight means NOTHING.

It is you who is doing the feminist movement damage.

And that is why I can't join you, no matter how much I would want to.

Grow up a bit and we'll talk. Hope that can be soon.

Your sister,

Goddessdeeva.

3 comments:

  1. This is a fucking beautiful letter. I'm sad to say I have friends who have bought into this hated, and it saddens and sickens me that hatred of marginalised groups is pushed in the name of liberation. We all need to stand together. Thank you for writing this.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thank you for reading it! We need to change things, hate isn't the way to do it.

    ReplyDelete
  3. sexuality and self are not exclusive binary concepts. they're a massive blurry grey morass of interchanging and moving elements that don't even stay the same from minute to minute.

    you can't be equal if you're excluding people, and if you have to resort to 'check your privilege' to win an argument, you're a tosser, and i don't care who you are or what side of some arbitrarily drawn line you stand on.

    feminism is a great thing. unfortunately, some people who choose to label themselves as feminists are anything but. and like with a great many things in life, it's the idiots who get the recognition and become associated with the label. meanwhile, the rest of us will end up having to start every conversation with 'no, that's not what it's really about.'

    ReplyDelete